The Relevance of Performance Tables in English Primary Schools

The publication of school performance tables has been well publiscised and the edition concerning 2010 has been available for a little while. The relevancy for secondary eduction relates to examination results at what is now called GCSE and equivalent which is generally at the age of 16, together with Key Stage 5 which is commonly referred to as A Levels at age 18. These two performance quotes are therefore relevant for academically capable children, and generally those schools which are selective in the students that enrol achieve higher percentages.

However, what should also be looked at is the results published at Key Stage 2 which is at Year 2 in Primary school. Again the results are dependent upon the general capability of the children in each year. Therefore, if a particular year has a higher than normal number of children with a statement of special education needs and that if there is an environment where children are not encouraged in their learning outside of school hours then it has to be recognised that teachers can only do so much to ensure that the relative streams of capability are challenged to the extent that shows progress. Maybe it needs to be recognised that the first 2 years of a child's life are the most important in terms of brain development and forming the basic bedrock for life and if this is not stimulated correctly then the early years is a case of trying to catch up which is not easy.

Therefore it really needs to be pointed out that these results need to be taken with a pinch of salt. My partner is a governor at our primary school which I see is really challenging our children and that they are taking up that challenge and also to enjoy education and life at school. In comparison to my early school years, the amount of home learning they have for spelling, reading and mathematics is amazing and therefore with this set curriculum you have to appreciate the work that teachers put into all of this and the amount of appraisal and reporting directly with parents on a regular basis that takes place. Yet if someone was to look at the performance tables for this school you could well be worried, which you should not be.

So do you rely on the the Ofsted report instead. Possibly but again it is very checklist tick box oriented but they do not tell you about that. Again comparing the primary school our children now attend with a previous one, and find that both are equated at very similar levels. My own opinion is that they are poles apart but this qualitative approach is not understood or undertaken in a review that does not give a complete view of the school's outlook and approach to the education of the children who are their students.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Google Maps and Spying

I have a statement to make. I use Google maps and the roadmap images to see what houses and areas look like. I also believe that certain members of my family use the same facility to effectively spy on me. The reason that I believe this is that until recently a member of this branch of the family sent occasional correspondence by post to us. However, recently Google has updated their images in this area, they are now showing images taken either in 2012 or 2013 and not 2008 or 2009 as was previously there. Funnily enough there is a vehicle on the driveway at the front of the house. It is not ours, and even somebody who knew us could tell that because the vehicle is not one that we would have, it just would not be one that we would have. The fact is I know whose vehicle it is and can therefore tell on which day of the week this picture was taken, even though I cannot tell on what date it was taken. Therefore, we are not receiving correspondence from this branch of the family (we do not g...
Read more

Barclays' Diamond Is Not Forever

July 3rd 2012, and Robert "Bob" Diamond, CEO of Barclays Bank resigned from his post following the further revelations of inappropriate business practices at the bank, relating to the setting of the London Inter-Bank Interest Rate or LIBOR. This follows the now infamous sounding out of the tax avoidance, or could it have been actually evasion schemes that the wealth management arm of the bank had been found out on and subjected to investiagations by the UK's HMRC. July 4th and he is required to attend the Treasury sub-committee of the British Parliament. Credit should be given that he did actually attend, unlike the CEO of Kraft Foods, but his performance in trying to show innocence as a whistleblower does not stack up. This is a part of a pattern where the whole banking sector is trying to play against each other in more and more desparate ways in order to substantiate profitability and justification for extremely high basic and overall salary packages. Shareholders ar...
Read more

Conservative Cutbacks

Well those boys in blue are putting on a show regarding their electability but beware because the reality is that where they are in power at a local level, their methodology for cutting back is pretty indiscriminate and will affect the delivery and performance of services. It is quite funny though that they are calling themselves the New Conservatives trying to copy the New Labour PR of 1997. I am not going to be convinced by all this and although Germany has decided to finish the SDP/Christian Democrats "alliance" in their recent elections, I am almost hoping that the next general election requires a coalition of at least the three main parties of Labour, LD and possibly Conservatives to bring out the best and hopefully not the worse. Otherwise the UK may be going down the path of mediocrity with no influence or wanting to really work in Europe, the final realisation that there never was a special relationship with the US, and a gradual decline in the fortitude and belief of...
Read more